Lab-grown diamonds have made larger diamonds dramatically more affordable—but their impact on natural diamonds varies greatly by size and quality. Here's what current price and carat-weight trends reveal about today's rapidly changing diamond market.

 

What You Will Learn

  • Why lab-grown diamonds have become so popular
  • How rapidly lab-grown diamond prices have fallen
  • Why engagement rings are getting larger
  • Which natural diamond sizes have been affected most
  • Why larger fine-quality natural diamonds are performing differently
  • What current trends may mean when buying, appraising or selling a diamond
  • Why purchase price and future resale value should not be confused

 

Lab-grown diamonds have changed the diamond business more dramatically than almost any development during my career.

Consumers can now purchase a large, attractive diamond for a fraction of what a comparable natural diamond would cost. That difference has altered expectations about size, price and what an engagement ring should look like.

But lab-grown diamonds have not affected every segment of the natural diamond market equally.

Smaller commercial-quality natural diamonds have experienced considerable pressure. One-carat engagement diamonds face intense competition. Yet fine natural diamonds of two carats and larger, particularly attractive stones with desirable color, clarity, cut and proportions, have generally held up considerably better.

In other words, we no longer have one diamond market. We have several.

 

Lab-Grown Diamonds Have Fundamentally Changed What Consumers Can Buy

A lab-grown diamond has essentially the same chemical composition and crystal structure as a natural diamond. What differs dramatically involves origin, rarity, production economics and market value.

Technology continues to make laboratory production more efficient. As supply increases, prices have fallen.

During 2025, approximately 61% of U.S. couples surveyed by The Knot selected a lab-grown center diamond for their engagement ring, up substantially from only a few years earlier.

That adoption has had another interesting effect.

Consumers are buying larger diamonds while spending less money.

The Knot reported that average engagement-ring center-stone size reached approximately 1.9 carats in 2025, compared with 1.7 carats during 2024. Average spending, however, dropped from approximately $5,200 to $4,600.

Lab-grown diamonds played a major role in creating that apparent contradiction.

The New Expectation: Bigger Diamonds

For generations, a one-carat diamond represented an important milestone.

Today, two-carat lab-grown engagement diamonds have become commonplace.

According to The Knot's 2025 data:

Natural diamond engagement ring

  • Average center diamond: approximately 1.6 carats
  • Average ring expenditure: approximately $7,000

Lab-grown diamond engagement ring

  • Average center diamond: approximately 2.0 carats
  • Average ring expenditure: approximately $4,300

Consumers therefore received roughly 25% more center-stone weight while spending thousands of dollars less.

That has reset visual expectations.

A one-carat diamond that once looked substantial may suddenly appear modest beside a two-, three- or even four-carat lab-grown diamond.

I sometimes refer to this phenomenon as diamond size inflation.

What Has Happened to Lab-Grown Diamond Prices?

Lab-grown diamond prices have declined dramatically as production has expanded.

Diamond-industry analyst Edahn Golan reports that his Lab-Grown Diamond Wholesale Price Index has fallen approximately 96% since tracking began in July 2018. During Q2 2026 alone, wholesale lab-grown diamond prices were another 13% lower than a year earlier.

Price declines have not been uniform by size.

Lab-Grown Price Trends by Size

Around 1 carat

This portion of the market may finally be approaching greater stability. Wholesale prices for one-carat round lab-grown diamonds actually increased approximately 1% year over year during Q2 2026.

One reason may be that consumers who once purchased one-carat lab-grown diamonds can now afford considerably larger stones.

1.50 to 1.99 carats

Wholesale prices declined approximately 11% year over year by Q2 2026.

Around 2 carats

Wholesale prices declined approximately 20% year over year.

Larger laboratory-grown diamonds have therefore experienced some of the strongest continuing price pressure.

As production becomes easier and less expensive, rarity does not increase proportionately with size in the way we traditionally associate with natural diamonds.

A One-Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Now Occupies a Very Different Price Category

BriteCo reported that during 2025 a natural one-carat diamond averaged approximately $4,200, although actual pricing varied considerably according to color, clarity, cut and other characteristics.

A comparable-size lab-grown diamond averaged roughly $1,000 or less.

Naturally, these averages should never be used to value an individual diamond. Diamond quality varies enormously.

But the price gap demonstrates why lab-grown diamonds have become so disruptive.

For consumers primarily interested in appearance, size and immediate purchase price, the value proposition can look very attractive.

What Has This Done to Natural Diamond Prices?

Lab-grown diamonds deserve part of the credit—or blame, depending upon your perspective—but they are not responsible for every decline in natural diamond prices.

Reduced demand from China, excess inventory, changing consumer behavior, geopolitical events and economic uncertainty have also affected natural diamond pricing.

Lab-grown diamonds have nevertheless created particularly strong competition in several important categories.

And this becomes much clearer when we examine natural diamonds by size.

Natural Diamonds Under One Carat Have Been Hit Hardest

Natural round diamonds from approximately 0.30 to 0.99 carats, particularly commercial-quality stones, suffered substantial pricing pressure during 2025.

Rapaport reported that consumers increasingly chose larger lab-grown diamonds rather than smaller or lower-quality natural stones. High inventories in the 0.30- to 0.69-carat range placed additional downward pressure on prices.

This segment contains many diamonds historically sold in moderately priced engagement rings and mainstream jewelry.

That consumer can now make a very different choice:

Buy a 0.50- or 0.75-carat natural diamond—or purchase a substantially larger lab-grown diamond for a similar budget.

Not surprisingly, many choose size.

Interestingly, Smaller Natural Diamonds Have Recently Shown Some Recovery

Markets rarely travel in a straight line.

During June 2026, Rapaport's index for 0.30-carat natural diamonds increased approximately 4.2% for the month, while 0.50-carat stones rose approximately 1.3%.

That does not erase several difficult years, but it suggests parts of the natural diamond market may be finding a new price equilibrium.

The One-Carat Natural Diamond Sits Directly in the Battleground

One carat remains one of the most important psychological sizes in diamond jewelry.

Unfortunately for natural diamond sellers, this also places one-carat diamonds directly against perhaps the strongest lab-grown value proposition.

Rapaport describes the one-carat engagement market as a defensive battle between natural and laboratory-grown diamonds. Lower-quality natural stones—with noticeable inclusions, poor make or undesirable characteristics—have encountered particularly weak demand.

Consumers increasingly ask:

If I can buy a clean-looking two-carat lab-grown diamond for similar money, why would I buy a mediocre one-carat natural diamond?

That question has forced natural-diamond sellers to concentrate more heavily on beauty, rarity, cutting quality and emotional value rather than carat weight alone.

Two Carats and Larger Tell a Different Story

Here we begin seeing a noticeable divergence.

Rapaport reported that the two-carat-and-larger luxury natural-diamond segment remained comparatively stable during 2025, especially for diamonds displaying fine quality, excellent proportions and desirable visual appearance.

Certain elongated fancy shapes of two carats and larger experienced particularly strong demand.

Marquise diamonds became exceptionally desirable. Ovals, elongated radiants and cushions also remained popular, although oversupply eventually softened some oval prices.

Why?

A consumer buying an important natural three-carat diamond may have very different motivations from someone simply looking for maximum visual size for a limited budget.

Rarity matters more.

Provenance may matter.

Natural origin matters.

Long-term desirability may matter.

A fine three-carat natural diamond remains genuinely scarce. A three-carat lab-grown diamond can simply be manufactured again.

Interestingly, Lab-Grown Demand May Have a Size Ceiling

There may also be a point where consumers begin feeling that a lab-grown diamond looks disproportionately large.

De Beers reported that sales of synthetic lab-grown diamonds at independent jewelers showed a noticeable decline once stones reached approximately three carats or larger.

That makes sense to me.

When a diamond becomes unusually large, people begin noticing it. A five-carat diamond historically communicated substantial rarity and wealth.

When laboratory production makes that appearance available at a relatively modest price, some consumers become uncomfortable with the disconnect.

Size alone no longer communicates value.

Natural Diamond Jewelry May Be Moving Upmarket

Another interesting trend has emerged.

Rather than disappearing, natural diamonds may gradually become more concentrated in premium and luxury jewelry.

De Beers' 2026 consumer research reported that average U.S. spending on natural diamond jewelry increased from approximately $3,242 per piece in 2023 to $4,063 during 2025.

Average total carat weight also increased from approximately 1.65 carats to 1.86 carats.

That suggests consumers who continue choosing natural diamonds may increasingly purchase larger, better or more important jewelry rather than competing directly with inexpensive laboratory-grown goods.

This could become one of the most important long-term changes in the diamond business.

Price and Value Are Not the Same Thing

Consumers should understand one important distinction.

A low purchase price can represent excellent value if your objective involves owning a large, beautiful diamond for personal enjoyment.

That does not mean the diamond will retain that value.

Lab-grown diamonds currently operate much more like a manufactured consumer product. Continuing improvements in production have repeatedly reduced the cost of producing comparable stones.

A diamond purchased for $4,000 several years ago might compete today with a newly manufactured diamond selling for substantially less.

That creates a difficult secondary market.

What About Resale Value?

This represents one of the biggest differences I see as an appraiser and jewelry broker.

Natural diamonds certainly do not automatically appreciate, and consumers should never purchase ordinary diamonds expecting an investment.

However, an established worldwide secondary market exists for natural diamonds.

Dealers buy them.

Manufacturers recut them.

Estate buyers purchase them.

Auction houses sell important examples.

Collectors seek unusual and exceptional stones.

Lab-grown diamonds have a much weaker secondary market because a buyer can often purchase a brand-new laboratory-grown stone at today's declining wholesale price.

Why purchase somebody's used lab-grown diamond unless the discount becomes substantial?

That does not make a lab-grown diamond a bad purchase.

It simply makes it a different type of purchase.

The Natural Diamond Market Has Become Much More Selective

Lab-grown diamonds have not eliminated demand for natural diamonds.

They have forced consumers to become more selective.

A poorly cut, visibly included, off-color commercial natural diamond can no longer rely simply upon being "natural."

Consumers have alternatives.

Natural diamonds increasingly need to offer something worth paying for:

beautiful cutting, attractive color, pleasing clarity, rarity, unusual size, distinctive shape, provenance or exceptional design.

That may ultimately produce a healthier fine-diamond market.

Ordinary diamonds face competition.

Exceptional diamonds remain exceptional.

My View of the Market by Size

Looking at today's market broadly, I would characterize it this way:

Under 0.50 carat:
Heavy competition and historically significant price pressure, although selected natural smalls showed recovery during mid-2026.

0.50 to 0.99 carat:
One of the more vulnerable natural-diamond categories. Consumers can easily trade into much larger lab-grown stones.

Around 1 carat:
The central battleground between natural and laboratory-grown diamonds. Fine natural stones remain desirable, while mediocre stones have become considerably harder to sell.

1.50 to 1.99 carats:
Increasing separation between commercial and premium natural goods. At the same time, declining lab-grown prices make two-carat appearance increasingly affordable.

2 to 3 carats:
Perhaps one of today's most interesting natural-diamond categories. Fine-quality natural diamonds have demonstrated considerably greater resilience, while lab-grown prices continue falling.

3 carats and larger:
Natural origin, rarity and quality become increasingly meaningful. Consumer enthusiasm for ever-larger lab-grown diamonds may also begin diminishing beyond approximately three carats.

Are Lab-Grown Diamonds Destroying the Natural Diamond Market?

I don't believe that accurately describes what is happening.

They are restructuring it.

Lab-grown diamonds have taken substantial market share from commercial natural diamonds, especially within engagement jewelry.

They have pushed diamond sizes dramatically higher.

They have placed downward pressure on prices.

They have forced jewelers to rethink margins and inventory.

And they have made consumers question what they are really paying for when they buy a diamond.

Yet natural diamonds retain something a laboratory-grown diamond cannot duplicate: geological rarity.

That distinction appears to become more important as diamond size, quality and value increase.

Final Thoughts

Lab-grown diamonds have created two increasingly different diamond markets.

One market focuses primarily on appearance, size and affordability.

Another increasingly focuses on rarity, natural origin, quality and long-term desirability.

Neither choice automatically represents a good or bad purchase.

Problems arise when consumers believe they are purchasing one while actually purchasing the other.

Before buying a significant diamond—natural or laboratory-grown—understand exactly what you are buying, what comparable stones currently sell for, and what realistic secondary-market value may look like.

That knowledge can make a very substantial financial difference.

Considering Buying, Selling or Appraising a Diamond?

Peter Indorf provides independent diamond appraisal, identification, valuation and consulting services through Jewelry Appraisal & Liquidation Solutions.

Whether you own a natural diamond, a laboratory-grown diamond, an antique-cut diamond or an important estate piece, proper identification and an understanding of today's changing market can help you make an informed decision.

A complimentary short appointment can help determine what you own, what type of appraisal or consultation may be appropriate, and what scope of work will be required.